Pacers Stun Knicks in Overtime Thriller: Game 1 Recap

Tyrese Haliburton makes choke gesture at Madison Square Garden after game tying shot.

In a breathtaking start to the 2025 Eastern Conference Finals, the Indiana Pacers overcame a significant deficit to defeat the New York Knicks 138-135 in overtime at Madison Square Garden. Tyrese Hailburton’s leadership and a historic shooting performance by Aaron Nesmith were pivotal in this comeback victory.

Haliburton Channels Reggie Miller in Clutch Performance

Tyrese Haliburton delivered a stellar performance with 31 points and 11 assists. His game trying jumper at the end of regulation forced overtime, and his subsequent “choke” gesture paid homage to Pacers legend Reggie Miller, igniting social media buzz.

Nesmith’s Historic Fourth-Quarter Shooting

Aaron Nesmith was instrumental in the Pacers’ comeback, scoring 20 points in the final five minutes of the fourth quarter, including six three pointers a playoff record for that timeframe.

Knicks’ Late-Game Collapse

The Knicks, leading by 14 points with under three minutes remaining, failed to maintain their advantage. Critical turnovers and missed free throws, including overtime and eventually secure the win.

Key Player Performances

  • Jalen Brunson: Led the Knicks with 43 points but missed a potential game tying three pointer in overtime.
  • Karl-Anthony Towns: Contributed 35 points and 12 rebounds but missed critical shots down the stretch.
  • Mikal Bridges: Struggled defensively, allowing Haliburton to excel.
  • OG Anunoby: Had a lackluster shooting night and missed a pivotal free throw in the closing seconds.

Historical Significance

This game market the first time in NBA playoff history that a team won after trailing by nine or more points in the final minute of regulation.